University College Dublin | An Coláiste Ollscoile, Baile Átha Cliath

UCD, Belfield, Dublin 4, Ireland | Director: Professor Liam Kennedy

Summer School 2008

Summer School 2008

Intellectuals and the Nation State

A Conference at the William Jefferson Clinton Auditorium
UCD Clinton Institute for American Studies
University College Dublin

30 Nov-1 Dec 2005

Intellectuals and The Nation-State Conference Report

Liam Kennedy

From 29th November to 1st December 2005, the UCD Clinton Institute for American Studies hosted its first international conference, devoted to discussion of 'Intellectuals and the Nation-State'. What role and effect do intellectuals have in the making and contesting of national identities and state policies? Ninety participants from more than twelve countries gathered to consider historical and current implications of this questions

Pictured on the first morning of the conference.

Pictured on the first morning of the conference.

The event got off to a terrific start with a public lecture by Professor Slavoj Zizek, the Slovenian philosopher who has developed a huge international readership. With a talk titled 'Ignorance of Chicken, or, The Limits of the Freedom of Thought', Professor Zizek did not disappoint a full lecture theatre of eager listeners, his talk inducing amusement and bemusement in about equal measure. There was a very lively Q&A and discussions continued into the reception held in Professor Zizek's honour.

Following this the conference moved into an intensive two days of plenary and panel sessions. The plenary sessions were all invigorating and developed some of the key themes. Professor Terry Eagleton (University of Manchester) spoke on Irish intellectuals and the idea of a public sphere. Professor Donald Pease (Dartmouth College) assessed the impact of a post-9/11 American Exceptionalism on frameworks of intellectual inquiry. Professor Eric Lott (University of Virginia) spoke on the cultural politics of 'baby boomer' intellectuals in the US.

Our closing plenary session, a roundtable discussion chaired by Professor Declan Kiberd (University College Dublin), with able support from Professor Donald Pease and Dr Conor McCarthy (Mater Dei Institute for Education), was an especially lively and thought-provoking session, as alsmost all conference participants pitched in their views and arguments.

Prof. Terry Eagleton in conversation with Prof. Liam Kennedy

Prof. Terry Eagleton in conversation with Prof. Liam Kennedy

The panel sessions interacted productively with the plenary sessions and with each other as speakers warmed to the themes and spoke on topics such as: the intellectual formations of neoconservatism; race and intellectual constituencies, the role of critical thinking and the value of ideas in the increasingly global 'knowledge society'; the role of intellectuals in government and in the formation of state policy; the relation of intellectuals to the national imaginary (several papers examined Irish intelletuals and intellectual formations). We are grateful to all who contributed so fully in their sessions and beyond.

Prof. Donald Pease (Dartmouth College), Prof. Declan Kiberd (UCD) and Dr. Conor McCarthy (Mater Dei Institute for Education) at the roundtable discussion. Prof. Donald Pease (Dartmouth College), Prof. Declan Kiberd (UCD) and Dr. Conor McCarthy (Mater Dei Institute for Education) at the roundtable discussion.

Prof. Luke Gibbons (Notre Dame), Prof. Donald Pease (Dartmouth College), Dr. Hamilton Carroll (CIAS) & Prof. Eric Lott (Univeresity of VirginiaProf. Luke Gibbons (Notre Dame), Prof. Donald Pease (Dartmouth College), Dr. Hamilton Carroll (CIAS) & Prof. Eric Lott (Univeresity of Virginia

Overall, this was a stimulating and productive event that is already receiving very positive feedback from participants. It has contributed to the development of our research networks and we look forward to building on this.We hope that the great intellectual energy of this conference will be a feature of future Clinton Institute events.

Prof. Liam Kenndy & Prof. Eric Lott (University of Virginia)

Prof. Liam Kenndy & Prof. Eric Lott (University of Virginia)

Prof. Slovaj Zizek & Prof Liam Kennedy

Prof. Slovaj Zizek & Prof Liam Kennedy

And the after photos!

Conference Programme - Tuesday 29th November

VENUE Q015, Quinn School of Business, UCD

6.00pm - 7.00pm Registration

7.oopm Keynote Lecture

Slavoj Zizek (Institute of Sociology, Ljubljana/Birkbeck Institute for the Humanities, London)

The Ignorance of Chicken, or, the Limits of the Freedom of Thought

8.30pm Reception

Wednesday 30th November

VENUE William Jefferson Clinton Auditorium, UCD

9.30am Welcome

Liam Kennedy (UCD Clinton Institute for American Studies)

10.00am Terry Eagleton

(University of Manchester)
Irish Intellectuals and the Public Sphere

11.00am Tea/Coffee

11.15am - 12.45pm

Panels A 1 - A 4

A1: Intellectuals and US Government

Amy E. Davis (UCLA), Intellectuals and Public Policy: Economists in the Kennedy Administration

David Milne (University of Nottingham), Walt Rostow, Stages of Economic Growth and the Vietnam War

A2: Intellectuals and the University

Bram Ieven (Leiden University), Passing through Thought: Politics of the University

Stephen Wallace (Bournemouth University),The Organisation of Ignorance

David Small (University of Canterbury),The Challenge of Being Critic and Conscience in a One-Size-Fits-All Society

A3: Europe

Bryan Ruppert (University of Birmingham), Advocating (Inter)National Identity: The Contribution of Post-War German Essayists to the Setting of New Objectives of State

Stefan Auer (UCD, DEI), Public Intellectuals, East and West: Jan Patocka and Václav Havel in Contention with Maurice Merleau-Ponty and Slavoj Zizek

Nevena Dakovic (University of Arts, Belgrade), EU Integrations and Serbian Intellectuals

A4: Race and Intellectual's Affiliation

Richard Ellis (University of Birmingham),David Walker, Walker's Appeal, Intellectualism and the Race Issue in 1820s America

Harilaos Stecopoulas (University of Iowa), The Empire Rag

Andreas Hess (University College Dublin), Strange Encounter of the Third Kind: W.E.B. DuBois and C.L.R James

12.45pm - 2.00pm Lunch

2.00pm - 3.30pm

Panels B1 - B4

B1: IrelandI

Eugene O'Brien (University of Limerick),Was ist{die neue} Aufklarung?: Towards a Redefinition of the Critical Intellectual in Contemporary Ireland

Rosemarie Rowley (Poet & Independent Scholar),The Role of the Intelligentsia as Dissidents in the Modern Nation State

Elaine Moriarty (Trinity College Dublin), Conceptualisations, Appropriations and Implications: A Critical Consideration of the Role of Intellectuals in Promoting 'In-Between' Discourses in the Quest to RE-imagine Irishness

B2: Philosophy and the State

Stefan Vogt (Duitsland-Instituut, University of Amsterdam),The "Socialist Decision": Paul Tillich's Search for an Alliance with Nationalism Against National Socialism

Toru Yamamori (University of Cambridge), Can Liberalism Go Beyond the Nation-States? Amartya Sen on Identity

B3: Global Intellectuals

Daniel Geary (University of Nottingham), "Becoming International Again": C. Wright Mills and the Global New Left

Ioana Luca (University of Bucharest), Speaking the Truth to Power: Edward Said's Memoir

Neil McLaughlin (McMaster University), Global Public Intellectuals and Academic Professions

B4: Intellectuals and Policy

Marshall DeRosa (Florida Atlantic University),Ideas Have Consequences: The Emerging Influence of European and World Jurisprudence on American Case Law

Richard Devine (Clark University),Political Opinion Influence Roles: Intellectuals and the State

Kelly L. Staples (University of Manchester),The Cosmopolitan Intellectual in Action: Onora O'Neill

3.30pm Tea/Coffee

4pm

Donald Pease (Dartmouth University)
American Studies After US Exceptionalism: The Responsibility of the Intellectual

back to top

Thursday 1st December

9.30am - 10.30am

Eric Lott (University of Virginia)
Waving the Flag: 9/11, Patriotism, and the Nation-State

10.30am Tea/Coffee

11.00am -12.30pm

Panels C1 - C4

C1: Ireland II

John Edwards (St Francis Xavier University),The Intellectual Presence in Nationalist Revival Efforts

Diarmuid Whelan (University College Cork),"The Kimmage Junta": The New Left Wing of the Irish Nation in Post-War Ireland

Bryan Fanning (University College Dublin),"Thinking for Ireland": The Bell and The Crane Bag as National Intellectual Projects

C2: Neoconservatism

Richard King (University of Nottingham),Why Are Straussians Conservatives - Or Art They?

Thomas Kane (University of Hull),The New New Rome? Machiavellianism in 21st Century American Foreign Policy

Maria Ryan (University of Birmingham),Neoconservatives and the State: The Dilemmas of Strategy and Ideology

C3: Action and Inaction

Alan Sandry (University of Wales Institute Cardiff),The Intellectuals' Conundrum: Neutralisty and the Nation-State

David Dwan (Queen's University Belfast),Metaphysically True, Politically False: The Intellectual in Politics

Gerardine Meeney (University College Dublin), Real Politics: Changing Realities and Imaging Death

C4: Other Americas

Joy Porter (University of Wales),The Dilemma of the Indigenous Intellectual in Relation to the Nation-State/Market State

Padraig Kirwan (The University of Dublin, Trinity College), The Sioux Writer and the Sioux Nation: Nationalism as Image in the Work of Elizabeth Cook-Lynn

Hamilton Carroll (University College Dublin ),Globalization, the Nation-State, and the Field Imaginaries of Contemporary American Studies

12.30pm Lunch

1.45pm - 3.15pm

Panels D1 - D4

D1: Transatlantic Perspectives

Holly J. Hutton (The New School, New York), French Intellectuals Reading America

Skaidra Trilupaityte (Culture, Philosophy and Art Research Institute, Vilnius),Intellectuals and Post-Cold War Transatlantic Rhetoric

Liam Kennedy (University College Dublin),European Intellectuals and American Empire

D2: Writing the Nation

Tom Keegan (University of Iowa), Saint Roger: The Ghost of Roger Casement in Irish Literature

Hanita Brand (Bar Ilan University),Three Egyptian Intellectual Writers

D3: New Formations

Paola Zaccaria (University of Bari),Black on White: Narration and Photography in the (Counter) Public Sphere

Aislinn O'Donnell (University College Dublin), Enlarging Our Mentality Beyond the Nation-State

Ulrike Auga (Humt University to Berlin),Intellectuals and the Gender Question at the Dawn of Transnational Constellations

3.15pm - 3.45pm Tea/Coffee

3.45pm - 5.15pm

Panels E1 - E4

E1: Political Intellectuals

Anne Kornhauser (Princeton University),Who is an American Intellectual? The Case of the German Emigires to the United States

Scott Lucas (University of Birmingham),Neither Right Nor Left: Intellectuals, Intervention, and the US State

Pierre Guerlain (Université Paris X Nanterre),Robert Kagan and Noam Chomsky: Two Ways of Being a Political Intellectual

E2: Postcolonial Conditions

Rosetta Sirico-Codling (Bircham International University),A Modest Proposal: Decolonising the Mind from Nervous Conditions

Paula Murphy (Mary Immaculate College),"What is Your Nation?": Psychoanalysis, Post-Colonialism and Multiracial Ireland

E3: Race and Intellectual Constituencies

Kristina Morris Baumli (University of Pennsylvania),A Southerner of a Different Stripe: Robert Penn Warren and Government Creation of Liberal Opposition to Martin Luther King Jr.

Markha Valenta (Free University, Amsterdam), Do We Dare Go Hungry?: Of Intellectuals and Their Constituencies in the Face of War-Or-Risking Islamism

5.15pm Tea/Coffee

5.45pm Round Table Discussion

back to top

Podcasts, Blogs & Videos

Analysing the latest issues & trends in the US, especialy in US Foreign Policy

Click here to view Libertas